Structural Steel Fire Protection Coatings vs Fire Retardant Paint for Fitting-Out: A Full Comparison of Fire Resistance Periods, BS 476 Test Standards, Regulatory Authorities, Coating Thickness and Inspection
Search for "fire retardant paint" in Hong Kong and you will often find two completely different answers. One is fitting-out fire retardant paint, applied to false ceilings, timber partitions and walls to slow the spread of flame across their surfaces. The other is structural fire protection coating, sprayed onto steel beams and columns to extend how long the steel structure keeps its load-bearing capacity in a fire. The names are similar and they may even look alike, but their purpose, test standards, regulatory authorities, application requirements and supporting documents are entirely different. Using the wrong product, or submitting the wrong documents, can lead to the work not being accepted. This guide starts from first principles and compares the two in full.
Quick answer: Fitting-out fire retardant paint deals with "surface spread of flame" on combustible fitting-out materials, assessed under BS 476 Part 7 Class 1 to Class 4. In Hong Kong licensed premises, it is generally applied by a Class 2 Registered Fire Service Installation Contractor who issues an FS251. Structural steel fire protection coating deals with the "fire resistance period" of steel in a fire, measured in minutes (for example 60, 90 or 120 minutes) and tested to standards such as BS 476 Parts 20/21 or EN 13381-8. The required coating thickness must be read from the product's tested data according to the steel section factor, fire resistance period and critical temperature. This falls under building structure, and generally needs to be designed and supervised by a building professional.
Contents
- The basic difference between the two "fire retardant paints"
- How their principles differ
- Test standards: Part 7 vs Parts 20/21
- Regulatory authorities and professional roles
- How steel fire protection coating thickness is determined
- Thin-film and thick-film steel fire protection coatings
- Differences in application and inspection
- Common mix-ups
- How to tell which one you need
- Frequently asked questions
1. The Basic Difference Between the Two "Fire Retardant Paints"
| Aspect | Fitting-out fire retardant paint | Structural steel fire protection coating |
|---|---|---|
| What it treats | Combustible fitting-out materials such as timber, plywood and fabric | Steel beams, steel columns and steel structural members |
| Purpose | Slows flame spread across the material surface | Slows the temperature rise of steel to maintain load-bearing capacity |
| How performance is expressed | BS 476 Part 7 Class 1 to Class 4 | Fire resistance period in minutes (e.g. 60, 90, 120 minutes) |
| Main test standards | BS 476 Part 7 | BS 476 Parts 20/21, EN 13381-8 and others |
| Typical applications | Fitting-out of licensed premises such as restaurants, shops, exhibition booths and schools | Steel-framed buildings, added steel platforms, steel staircases, industrial and commercial buildings |
| Main authority involved | Fire Services Department (fire safety requirements for licensed premises) | Buildings Department (building structure and fire resisting construction requirements) |
| Coating quantity | Coverage and number of coats as listed for the product on the FSD list | Dry film thickness read from the product's test data according to section factor, fire resistance period and critical temperature |
| Common supporting documents | Test report or FS251 | Product test and assessment reports, thickness measurement records and relevant documents from building professionals |
Put simply, fitting-out fire retardant paint is about "will fire spread quickly across walls and ceilings?", while structural steel fire protection coating is about "can the building stay standing long enough in a fire?". The former protects escape time and the indoor environment; the latter protects structural safety. For the basics of fitting-out fire retardant paint, see What Is Fire Retardant Paint? Principles, Types and Hong Kong Fire Safety Requirements.
2. How Their Principles Differ
Fitting-Out Fire Retardant Paint: Limiting Surface Burning
Materials such as timber and fabric burn. Once flame reaches the surface, it can spread rapidly across it. Fitting-out fire retardant paint foams, chars or releases non-combustible gases when heated, making the surface harder to ignite and slowing flame spread. Its aim is to raise the material's surface spread of flame performance to BS 476 Part 7 Class 1 or Class 2.
Structural Steel Fire Protection Coating: Slowing Steel Temperature Rise
Steel itself does not burn, but it gradually loses strength at high temperatures. Under design loads, the critical temperature of ordinary structural steel is usually about 550°C; for more heavily loaded members, it may be lower. Structural steel fire protection coatings expand in a fire to form an insulating layer that slows the transfer of heat to the steel, keeping it below its critical temperature for the specified period.
So although both may use the "intumescent" principle, one stops a material "catching fire and spreading flame", while the other stops steel "getting so hot it loses strength". They tackle different problems, and their formulations, thicknesses and test methods are completely different. One cannot replace the other.
3. Test Standards: Part 7 vs Parts 20/21
BS 476 is a series of British fire test standards, with different parts testing different performance:
| BS 476 part | What it tests | Applies to |
|---|---|---|
| Part 7 | Lateral surface spread of flame | Fitting-out fire retardant paint, wall and ceiling materials |
| Part 20 | General principles for testing fire resistance of elements of construction | The basis for fire resistance tests of elements |
| Part 21 | Fire resistance of loadbearing elements (e.g. steel beams and columns) | Structural steel fire protection coatings |
| Part 22 | Fire resistance of non-loadbearing elements (e.g. fire doors and partitions) | Fire doors, fire-resisting partitions |
In recent years, many structural steel fire protection coatings have also been assessed under the European standard EN 13381-8, which specifically assesses the contribution of reactive protection (i.e. intumescent coatings) applied to steel members to their fire resistance. Product data may cite both BS 476 Part 21 and EN 13381-8. The two use different test approaches, so always follow the standard set by the design requirements and specified by the building professional.
How Fire Resistance Periods Are Expressed
Hong Kong building fire safety codes express fire resistance as three figures for "stability / integrity / insulation", for example "-/60/60":
- Stability: how long the element keeps its load-bearing capacity in a fire, which is especially important for loadbearing steel beams and columns.
- Integrity: how long the element prevents flames and hot gases from passing through.
- Insulation: how long the temperature on the unexposed face stays below the limit.
Structural steel fire protection coatings mainly address the stability requirement of loadbearing elements. How many minutes a particular element needs is determined by a building professional according to the Code of Practice for Fire Safety in Buildings and the building's use, height and floor area, not by the coating supplier or contractor.
Why a Part 7 Report Cannot Be Used for Steel Structures
BS 476 Part 7 only tests surface spread of flame and says nothing about how long an element can stand up in a fire. A fitting-out fire retardant paint that achieves Part 7 Class 1 does not prove that a steel beam it is applied to has any fire resistance period. Conversely, a Part 21 report for a structural steel coating cannot prove that a timber partition meets Part 7. This is the most common confusion between the two, and the one most likely to cause inspection problems. For details of Part 7, see BS 476 Part 7 Class 1 vs Class 2.
4. Regulatory Authorities and Professional Roles
Fitting-Out Fire Retardant Paint: FSD Requirements for Licensed Premises
Flammability requirements for false ceilings, partitions and wall finishes in licensed premises such as restaurants, schools and places of amusement are set by the FSD in the fire safety requirements for each type of premises. Non-compliant materials must be treated by a Class 2 Registered Fire Service Installation Contractor with a fire retardant paint or solution accepted by the Director of Fire Services, and an FS251 submitted. For the full process, see The Fire Retardant Paint Process Explained: 12 Steps to FS251.
Structural Steel Fire Protection Coating: Buildings Department Requirements
Fire resistance requirements for steel structures fall under building structure and fire resisting construction, with reference mainly to the Buildings Department's Code of Practice for Fire Safety in Buildings 2011 and Code of Practice for the Structural Use of Steel 2011. New or altered works involving steel structures are generally building works or minor works under the Buildings Ordinance and must follow the Buildings Department's procedures. Under the Minor Works Control System, all minor works must be carried out by prescribed registered contractors, and Class I minor works also require a prescribed building professional (such as an Authorized Person or Registered Structural Engineer) to be appointed to design and supervise them.
| Role | Fitting-out fire retardant paint | Structural steel fire protection coating |
|---|---|---|
| Setting requirements | FSD (requirements for licensed premises) | Buildings Department codes; determined by building professionals according to the building |
| Design and specification | Materials assessed by a registered contractor according to FSD requirements | Authorized Person or Registered Structural Engineer specifies the fire resistance period and protection method |
| Application | Class 2 Registered Fire Service Installation Contractor | Qualified contractors or specialist applicators, depending on the nature of the works |
| Main documents | Test report or FS251 | Product test and assessment data, thickness measurement records, documents from building professionals |
The actual division of roles varies with the nature of the works. For works involving steel fire protection, first consult the Authorized Person or Registered Structural Engineer responsible for the project to confirm the required fire resistance period, applicable standards and documents to be submitted, rather than buying products directly from a paint or fire retardant paint supplier.
5. How Steel Fire Protection Coating Thickness Is Determined
There is no universal figure for structural steel fire protection coatings along the lines of "this thickness gives this many minutes". The required dry film thickness depends on four factors:
1. Section Factor Hp/A
The section factor is the heated perimeter of the steel member (Hp) divided by its cross-sectional area (A), in units of m⁻¹. It reflects the ratio of the surface exposed to heat to the steel's mass:
- High section factor: light, thin members have a relatively large heated surface, heat up quickly and need thicker coatings.
- Low section factor: heavy, thick members heat up more slowly and need thinner coatings.
Section factors for structural steel range from about 50 m⁻¹ for heavy columns to 350 m⁻¹ or more for light beams or hollow sections. Whether a member is heated on three sides (such as a beam supporting a floor slab) or four sides also affects the calculation.
2. Required Fire Resistance Period
Common requirements are 30, 60, 90 and 120 minutes, and critical structures may need longer. The longer the fire resistance period, the greater the thickness required, and the increase is often not proportional. For light members, going from 60 to 120 minutes may more than double the required thickness.
3. Critical Temperature
The critical temperature is calculated by the structural engineer based on the loading on the member. Ordinary structural steel is often referenced at 550°C, but more heavily loaded members have lower critical temperatures and need thicker coatings.
4. Fire Curve
Ordinary buildings use the standard cellulosic fire curve, while sites such as petrochemical facilities may use the faster-rising hydrocarbon fire curve, which places entirely different demands on the coating.
Reading the Thickness from the Product Data Table
With this information, the required dry film thickness must be read from the data table for the chosen product, based on testing and assessment by an accredited laboratory, according to section factor and fire resistance period. These tables apply only to that product; data from different manufacturers cannot be mixed. Within the same building, the required thickness for steel members of different sizes can vary greatly, so a proper specification will often list different thickness requirements for each type of member.
| Information | Provided by |
|---|---|
| Required fire resistance period | Determined by the building professional according to codes and the building |
| Steel member sizes and number of heated faces | Structural drawings |
| Section factor | Calculated from member sizes or read from tables |
| Critical temperature | Calculated by the structural engineer |
| Required dry film thickness | Read from the product's tested data table |
6. Thin-Film and Thick-Film Steel Fire Protection Coatings
| Aspect | Thin-film intumescent coating | Thick-film coating |
|---|---|---|
| Common base | Water-based or solvent-based | Mostly epoxy-based |
| Reaction to heat | Expands rapidly, up to 20 to 50 times its original thickness | Expands more slowly, with a thicker coating to begin with |
| Appearance | Smoother finish that keeps the look of the steel structure | Thicker coating with a rougher appearance |
| Common uses | General indoor steelwork and exposed steel designs | Harsher environments and sites needing higher durability |
| Application requirements | Multiple coats, with thickness controlled per coat | Higher application and curing requirements |
Besides coatings, steel structures can also meet fire resistance requirements through fire-rated board encasement, sprayed fire protection materials or concrete encasement. The choice depends on the fire resistance period, appearance requirements, space constraints, environmental conditions and cost, and should be decided by a building professional.
7. Differences in Application and Inspection
| Item | Fitting-out fire retardant paint | Structural steel fire protection coating |
|---|---|---|
| Surface preparation | Clean, dry, and confirmed unpainted | Rust removal and cleaning, with a compatible primer applied as the system requires |
| Application control | Coverage and number of coats controlled to product requirements | Applied in coats to the dry film thickness specified for each type of member |
| Topcoat | If a topcoat is needed, compatibility must be confirmed | The system generally includes primer, fire protection coat and topcoat, which must be applied as specified |
| Completion check | Check the scope, area and product | Measure dry film thickness with suitable instruments and record the results |
| Main documents | Test report or FS251 | Product assessment data, thickness measurement records and professional documents |
Dry Film Thickness Measurement
The key to inspecting structural steel fire protection coatings is confirming that every member's dry film thickness meets the specification. Thickness is generally measured with gauges based on magnetic induction or eddy current principles, with readings taken and recorded at different points on each member using the specified method. Members with insufficient thickness must be recoated until they comply. This is clearly different from fitting-out fire retardant paint, where inspection mainly checks the treated scope and product.
8. Common Mix-Ups
Scenario 1: Applying Fitting-Out Fire Retardant Paint to Steel Beams
Situation: an owner assumes "all fire retardant paint is the same" and applies fitting-out fire retardant paint to exposed steel beams.
Problem: the formulation and coverage of fitting-out fire retardant paint are designed to slow surface flame spread, and there is no steel fire resistance test data for it, so it cannot prove that the beams have the required fire resistance period.
Recommendation: first have a building professional confirm whether the beams need fire protection and for how long, then choose a steel fire protection system tested to the corresponding standard.
Scenario 2: Exposed Steel Features in a Restaurant
Situation: an industrial-style restaurant uses exposed steel beams as a design feature, together with a timber grille ceiling.
Problem: the timber grille is a fitting-out material and must meet BS 476 Part 7; whether the steel beams involve structural fire resistance requirements is a separate matter.
Recommendation: handle the two separately. Treat the timber grille according to licensed premises requirements and obtain an FS251; if the steel beams are structural members, consult a building professional. For fitting-out material requirements in restaurants, see Fire Retardant Paint and False Ceiling Requirements for Restaurants.
Scenario 3: Adding a Steel Mezzanine or Platform
Situation: a shop or industrial unit adds a steel mezzanine.
Problem: adding a steel structure is generally building works or minor works, which must comply with Buildings Department requirements; it cannot be dealt with simply by applying fire retardant paint.
Recommendation: first appoint a building professional to assess the category of works and the procedures required, then decide on the structural fire protection method.
Scenario 4: Steel Work Quoted as Fitting-Out Fire Retardant Paint
Situation: a quotation states "steel structure fire retardant paint, so many dollars per square metre", without specifying the fire resistance period, dry film thickness or product test standard.
Problem: the cost of structural steel fire protection coating depends mainly on the required thickness, which can vary several-fold between members. A quotation priced by area alone, without a thickness specification, makes it hard to confirm compliance.
Recommendation: ask for the quotation to specify the fire resistance period, dry film thickness for each type of member, the product used and its test standard, and arrangements for measuring thickness on completion.
9. How to Tell Which One You Need
Use the following questions for an initial assessment:
| Question | If the answer is "yes" |
|---|---|
| Is the item to be treated a fitting-out material such as timber, plywood or fabric? | It falls under fitting-out fire retardant paint |
| Does the requirement come from FSD requirements for licensed premises, or exhibition venue rules? | It falls under fitting-out fire retardant paint |
| Do the documents specify BS 476 Part 7 Class 1 or Class 2? | It falls under fitting-out fire retardant paint |
| Is the item a steel beam, steel column or loadbearing steel member? | It falls under structural steel fire protection |
| Is the requirement expressed as a fire resistance period in minutes? | It falls under steel structure or fire-resisting element protection |
| Do the works involve additions, structural alterations or Buildings Department procedures? | It falls under structural steel fire protection; consult a building professional |
Information to Provide When Enquiring
Fitting-out fire retardant paint: premises use, material types and areas, surface condition, site photos and any FSD letter of requirements. For cost factors, see How Much Does Fire Retardant Paint Cost in Hong Kong?.
Structural steel fire protection coating: structural drawings, steel member sizes and quantities, required fire resistance period, the building professional's specification, application environment (indoor or outdoor) and appearance requirements.
When Both Requirements Apply
Many projects involve both types of fire safety requirement, such as industrial-style restaurants, exhibition halls and clubhouse lobbies. When handling them:
- Draw up two separate lists: "fitting-out materials" and "structural members".
- Treat fitting-out materials according to licensed premises or venue requirements, and obtain test reports or an FS251.
- Treat structural members according to the building professional's specification, and keep product assessment data and thickness records.
- File the two sets of documents separately, so that one type of document is never used to address the other type of requirement.
- If steel members are exposed within the fitted-out area, confirm that any topcoat is compatible with the steel fire protection system.
For whether different materials can take fitting-out fire retardant treatment, see Which Materials Can Be Fire Retardant Treated?.
10. Frequently Asked Questions
Can structural steel fire protection coatings and fitting-out fire retardant paint be used interchangeably?
No. Fitting-out fire retardant paint targets surface spread of flame and is assessed under BS 476 Part 7. Structural steel fire protection coatings target the fire resistance period of elements and are assessed under standards such as BS 476 Parts 20/21 or EN 13381-8. Their formulations, thicknesses and test data are completely different.
How thick should structural steel fire protection coating be?
There is no universal figure. The required dry film thickness depends on the steel section factor Hp/A, the required fire resistance period, the critical temperature and the fire curve, and must be read from the chosen product's tested data table. Thickness can vary greatly between members.
What is the section factor Hp/A?
The section factor is the heated perimeter of the steel member divided by its cross-sectional area, in m⁻¹. The higher the value, the lighter and thinner the member, the faster it heats up and the thicker the fire protection coating it needs.
What does "-/60/60" mean?
This is how fire resistance periods are expressed. The three figures give the minutes for stability, integrity and insulation respectively, with "-" meaning that criterion does not apply. For example, "-/60/60" means both integrity and insulation must reach 60 minutes.
Does structural steel fire protection coating need an FS251?
The FS251 is mainly used for fire service installations and equipment, and for cases where combustible fitting-out materials in licensed premises are treated with fire retardant paint or solution. Steel fire resistance falls under building structure, and the documents required are generally determined by the building professional responsible for the project according to Buildings Department requirements. Confirm with the professional in advance.
How do I choose between thin-film and thick-film steel fire protection coatings?
Thin-film coatings have a smoother finish and suit general indoor use and designs that keep the look of the steel. Thick-film coatings are mostly used in harsher environments or where higher durability is needed. The actual choice should be made by a building professional according to the fire resistance period, environment and appearance requirements.
How is structural steel fire protection coating inspected on completion?
Mainly by measuring the dry film thickness of each member with a suitable gauge to confirm it meets the specification, and recording the results. Areas with insufficient thickness must be recoated.
Do exposed steel beams in a restaurant need fire protection?
It depends on whether the beams are structural members and on the building's fire resistance requirements. This falls under building structure and should be assessed by a building professional. Fitting-out materials in the restaurant, such as timber and fabric, must be treated according to the FSD's licensed premises requirements.
Can an added steel mezzanine simply be painted with fire retardant paint?
Adding a steel structure is generally building works or minor works, which must follow Buildings Department procedures and be designed and supervised by qualified persons. The structural fire protection method must be specified by a professional according to the codes; applying fire retardant paint alone is not enough.
Fitting-Out Fire Safety Enquiries
Grand United Eng., Co. is a Registered Fire Service Installation Contractor in Hong Kong. We mainly help licensed premises, shops and exhibition booths meet fire safety requirements for fitting-out materials, including assessing false ceilings, partitions, wall finishes and fabrics, and arranging fire retardant paint or solution treatment and the FS251. If your project also involves steel structure fire protection, we can help separate the two sets of requirements and work alongside the building professional responsible for the project. When you contact us, please provide the premises use, a material list, site photos and any relevant notices. You can also browse our Fire Engineering Services, Project Cases and FAQ.
Enquire about fitting-out fire retardant treatment, or call 2667 7701.
