Fire Buckets, Fire Extinguishers or Fire Blankets: How to Choose? A Full Comparison of Portable Fire-Fighting Appliances, Fire Classes, Specifications and Provision by Premises

The first few dozen seconds of a fire often decide whether it can be brought under control. Yet using the wrong appliance can backfire: spraying water on electrical equipment risks electric shock, pouring water on a wok fire can make hot oil explode outwards, and discharging large amounts of carbon dioxide in a closed room can cause suffocation. Fire buckets (sand buckets), fire extinguishers and fire blankets are all "portable equipment", but each targets different fires. Based on information from the Fire Services Department (FSD), this guide compares the uses, limits and provision of each type of portable fire-fighting appliance, and offers a simple selection process.

Quick answer: Sand buckets are for small fires involving flammable liquids spilled on the floor. Water extinguishers are for ordinary solid fires such as wood, paper and fabric, but must not be used on electrical equipment, flammable liquids or metals. Foam extinguishers are for flammable liquids. Dry powder extinguishers suit most fires, including flammable liquids and electrical equipment. CO2 extinguishers are for electrical equipment, flammable liquids and delicate instruments. Fire blankets are for small fires such as wok or pan fires in kitchens. When choosing, first identify the main fire risks in the premises, then provide suitable appliances. All fire extinguishers and fire blankets must be approved by the FSD.

Contents

  1. What is portable equipment?
  2. Understanding fire classes
  3. Overview of each appliance
  4. Each type of fire extinguisher in detail
  5. Fire blankets: heavy-duty and light-duty
  6. Where sand buckets fit in
  7. Discharge range, duration and capacity compared
  8. Provision advice by premises
  9. A five-step selection process
  10. The PASS method for using a fire extinguisher
  11. Frequently asked questions

1. What Is Portable Equipment?

Under section 2 of the Fire Service (Installations and Equipment) Regulations (Cap. 95B), portable equipment means any fire service equipment that is manufactured, used or designed to be used as a self-contained unit for extinguishing, attacking, preventing or limiting a fire. Common portable equipment includes:

To ensure effectiveness and safety, portable equipment such as fire extinguishers and fire blankets must be approved by the Director of Fire Services under section 3 of Cap. 95B before it can be sold or supplied in Hong Kong. Sand buckets must meet the specification set out in the FSD code; see What Are Fire Buckets and Sand Buckets?.

2. Understanding Fire Classes

Before choosing a fire-fighting appliance, understand what kinds of fire could occur in the premises. Common classes are:

ClassWhat burnsCommon examples in Hong Kong
Class AOrdinary combustible solidsPaper, wood, fabric, plastics, rubbish, cardboard boxes
Class BFlammable liquidsPetrol, diesel, kerosene, solvents, paint, paint thinner, alcohol
Class CFlammable gasesLPG, town gas
Class DCombustible metalsIndustrial metals such as magnesium and aluminium powder
Class FCooking oils and fatsWoks, pans, deep fryers
Electrical firesLive equipmentPower strips, computers, switchboards, air conditioners

The same premises may face several types of risk at once. A restaurant kitchen, for example, has cooking oil (Class F), electrical equipment and town gas, while an office mainly has paper (Class A) and electrical equipment.

3. Overview of Each Appliance

ApplianceSuitable forNot suitable forCommon locations
Water extinguisherOrdinary solids such as wood, cotton fabrics and paperElectrical equipment, flammable liquids, metalsOffices, shopping malls, schools
Foam extinguisherFlammable liquids, ordinary solidsElectrical equipmentGarages, fuel stores, workshops
Dry powder extinguisherMost fires, including flammable liquids, metals and electrical equipmentDelicate equipment (powder is hard to clean up)Homes, shops, car parks, industrial buildings
CO2 extinguisherElectrical equipment, flammable liquids, delicate instruments, important documentsDeep-seated solid fires (prone to re-ignition)Computer rooms, switch rooms, laboratories
Fire blanketBurning flammable liquids, small kitchen or laboratory fires, wok or pan firesLarge firesHome kitchens, restaurant kitchens, laboratories
Sand bucketSmall fires involving flammable liquids spilled on the floor, containing fuel leaksWok or pan fires, electrical fires, fires at heightGenerator rooms, fuel tank rooms, construction sites

4. Each Type of Fire Extinguisher in Detail

Water Extinguishers

How it works: water cools the burning material and lowers its temperature.
Suitable for: FSD information states that water extinguishers are suitable for fighting burning wood, cotton fabrics, paper and similar materials.
Never: use on burning electrical equipment, flammable liquids or metals.
Strengths: good cooling effect, more effective on deep-seated solid fires, no chemical residue.
Limits: narrow range of use, with risks of electric shock and spreading oil fires.

Foam Extinguishers

How it works: foam covers the liquid surface, cutting off air and cooling it.
Suitable for: burning flammable liquids such as kerosene, petrol and alcohol; also usable on ordinary solids.
Never: use on electrical fires.
Strengths: covers the liquid surface, reducing the risk of re-ignition.
Limits: unsuitable for electrical equipment; foam must be cleaned up after use.

Dry Powder Extinguishers

How it works: dry powder interrupts the chemical reaction of combustion and covers the burning material.
Suitable for: FSD information states that dry powder extinguishers are suitable for most fires, such as burning flammable liquids, metals or electrical equipment. The FSD also suggests dry powder extinguishers are more suitable for general home use.
Strengths: the widest range of use and relatively economical.
Limits: reduces visibility when discharged, the powder is hard to clean up and may damage delicate equipment, and not every dry powder is suitable for every metal fire, so follow the label on the cylinder.

CO2 Extinguishers

How it works: carbon dioxide displaces oxygen and also has a cooling effect.
Suitable for: FSD information states that CO2 extinguishers are suitable for burning electrical equipment, flammable liquids, delicate instruments or important documents.
Strengths: non-conductive, leaves no residue and does not damage delicate equipment.
Limits: carbon dioxide can cause suffocation, so after use in a poorly ventilated space, leave quickly and ventilate it. The horn becomes extremely cold, so hold the handle. It does not cool deep-seated solid fires enough, so they may re-ignite.

Other Types

The market also offers clean agent extinguishers and wet chemical extinguishers designed for commercial deep fryers. Before using one, confirm that it is approved by the FSD and check the cylinder label for its range of use.

5. Fire Blankets: Heavy-Duty and Light-Duty

Fire blankets are made of fire-resisting material and are used by completely covering the source of the fire to cut off air. FSD information states that fire blankets are suitable for extinguishing burning flammable liquids and small fires in kitchens or laboratories, and are especially suitable for small fires caused by oil burning in a pan while cooking.

Two Types of Fire Blanket

TypeStandardAccepted as equipment required by the FSD?
Heavy-duty fire blanketBS 7944:1999Yes (must be reusable)
Light-duty fire blanketBS EN 1869:1997No

The FSD's Fire Protection Notice No. 11 states that only "heavy-duty" and reusable fire blankets can be accepted as equipment required by the FSD. In other words, where the FSD's written requirements call for a fire blanket in the premises, such as a restaurant kitchen, a heavy-duty fire blanket should be chosen. Fire blankets bought for home use are not bound by this requirement, but should still be FSD-approved products.

Key Points for Using a Fire Blanket

  1. Turn off the heat or fuel source.
  2. Pull out the fire blanket and wrap it around your hands to protect them.
  3. Lay the blanket over the fire, working from the near side to the far side to cover it completely and avoid hot oil splashing towards you.
  4. Keep it covered until everything has cooled completely; do not lift it too early.
  5. If the fire has spread to the cooker hood or kitchen cabinets, evacuate immediately and call the fire services.

6. Where Sand Buckets Fit In

The sand bucket is the simplest portable appliance, with no pressure or moving parts. It is mainly used on small fires involving flammable liquids spilled on the floor, and to contain fuel leaks that have not yet caught fire. Its strengths are reliability, no need for pressurisation and simple maintenance. Its limit is that it can only deal with small fires at floor level, and is unsuitable for wok or pan fires, electrical fires and fires at height.

ComparisonSand bucketFoam or dry powder extinguisher
Small fuel fire on the floorSuitableSuitable
Containing a leak that has not caught fireSuitable; absorbs liquidNot suitable
Fighting a fire from a distanceNot suitable; must get closeCan be used from several metres away
Pressure and moving partsNonePressure must be maintained
MaintenanceCheck sand level and drynessRegular checks and testing as required

In generator rooms, fuel tank rooms and other places with higher flammable liquid risks, sand buckets are often provided together with foam, dry powder or CO2 extinguishers, so that each complements the other.

7. Discharge Range, Duration and Capacity Compared

Discharge range and duration vary greatly between extinguisher types, affecting how close the user must stand and how much time they have to fight the fire. The following is a general reference:

TypeDischarge range (approx.)Discharge time (approx.)Typical capacity
Water6 m60 seconds9 litres
Foam4 to 6 m50 secondsDepends on model
Dry powder1.5 to 4 m8 to 20 seconds5 kg and others
CO21 to 2 m8 to 20 seconds4.5 kg and others

As the table shows, dry powder and CO2 extinguishers discharge for only a dozen or so seconds, so the user must aim at the base of the fire before discharging. Actual performance depends on the product model and cylinder label.

8. Provision Advice by Premises

The following is general advice. For licensed premises, the type, number and location of appliances follow the written requirements of the FSD or licensing authority.

SettingMain risksSuggested provision
HomesWok or pan fires, electrical equipment, clutterDry powder extinguisher, fire blanket
Restaurant kitchensCooking oil, town gas, electrical equipmentHeavy-duty fire blanket, CO2 or other suitable extinguishers
OfficesPaper, electrical equipmentWater and CO2 extinguishers, or dry powder extinguishers
Computer rooms, switch roomsElectrical and delicate equipmentCO2 extinguishers
Generator rooms, fuel tank roomsDiesel, electrical equipmentSand buckets, dry powder, foam or CO2 extinguishers
Garages, workshopsEngine oil, solvents, electrical equipmentSand buckets, foam or dry powder extinguishers
Construction sitesFuel-powered machinery, hot work, debrisSand buckets, dry powder and water extinguishers
LaboratoriesChemicals, electrical equipmentFire blankets, CO2 extinguishers, sand buckets (depending on chemicals)
Exhibition booths and temporary eventsTimber structures, electrical equipmentAs required by the organiser; commonly water and CO2 extinguishers

Fire safety requirements for restaurants generally include CO2 extinguishers, water extinguishers and fire blankets; see Fire Retardant Paint and False Ceiling Requirements for Restaurants. For exhibition booth requirements, see Fire Safety Requirements for Exhibition Booths and Mall Events.

9. A Five-Step Selection Process

  1. List the risks: what could burn in the premises? Paper and wood, flammable liquids, cooking oil, electrical equipment, gas or metals?
  2. Check the requirements: is the premises licensed? Has the FSD or licensing authority issued written requirements? If so, provide appliances accordingly.
  3. Choose appliances by risk: using the overview table in this guide, choose a suitable appliance for each type of risk.
  4. Consider the environment: is there delicate equipment (avoid dry powder), is the space enclosed (take care with CO2), and is it damp (sand buckets must be kept dry)?
  5. Check approval and labels: fire extinguishers and fire blankets must be FSD-approved; read the cylinder label to confirm the range of use, and arrange regular checks.

An Example

Consider a café with a small kitchen. The kitchen has cooking oil and electrical equipment, while the seating area mainly has paper, fabric and electrical equipment. Following the process above, the kitchen would be best provided with a heavy-duty fire blanket and an extinguisher suitable for electrical and oil fires, while the seating area could have water and CO2 extinguishers, or dry powder extinguishers. The actual type and number follow the FSD's written requirements.

10. The PASS Method for Using a Fire Extinguisher

Most fire extinguishers can be used in four PASS steps:

  1. Pull: pull out the safety pin.
  2. Aim: aim at the base of the fire, not the top of the flames.
  3. Squeeze: squeeze the operating lever.
  4. Sweep: sweep from side to side across the base of the fire until it is out.

Before using one, make sure you have a safe escape route and stand upwind. If the fire grows or smoke becomes thick, evacuate immediately and call 999.

11. Frequently Asked Questions

Which fire extinguisher should I buy for my home?

The FSD suggests that dry powder extinguishers are more suitable for general home use, because they can put out different types of fire, such as those involving flammable liquids, metals or electrical equipment. A fire blanket can also be added for the kitchen.

Which fire extinguisher should be used on an electrical fire?

A CO2 or dry powder extinguisher can be used, after first cutting off the power if it is safe to do so. Never use water or foam extinguishers, to avoid electric shock.

What should I use on a wok or pan fire?

First turn off the heat, then cover the pan completely with a fire blanket or lid to cut off air, and keep it covered until it has cooled. Never use water, or hot oil will splash everywhere.

Are there different types of fire blanket?

Yes. Fire blankets are either "heavy-duty", meeting BS 7944:1999, or "light-duty", meeting BS EN 1869:1997. Only heavy-duty and reusable fire blankets can be accepted as equipment required by the FSD.

What fires can a water extinguisher be used on?

It is suitable for fires in ordinary solids such as burning wood, cotton fabrics and paper. Never use it on electrical equipment, flammable liquids or metals.

What are the dangers of CO2 extinguishers?

Carbon dioxide can cause suffocation, so after using one in a poorly ventilated space, leave quickly and ventilate it. The horn becomes extremely cold, so hold the handle to avoid frostbite.

Which is better, a sand bucket or a fire extinguisher?

They have different uses and do not replace each other. Sand buckets suit small fires involving flammable liquids spilled on the floor and containing leaks, while fire extinguishers can be used from several metres away and have a wider range of use. Places with higher flammable liquid risks usually have both.

Can I use a fire extinguisher bought online?

Fire extinguishers and fire blankets must be approved by the Director of Fire Services under section 3 of Cap. 95B before they can be sold or supplied in Hong Kong. Before buying, confirm that the product is FSD-approved portable equipment.

How many fire extinguishers does a premises need?

For licensed premises, the number and location follow the written requirements of the FSD or licensing authority. Other premises can provide appliances according to floor area, number of floors and risk locations, so that an appliance is within easy reach from anywhere.

Can I tell the type of fire extinguisher by its colour?

Do not rely on colour alone. Read the cylinder label to confirm the extinguishing agent, suitable fires and limits of use.

Portable Fire Equipment Provision Enquiries

Grand United Eng., Co. is a Registered Fire Service Installation Contractor in Hong Kong. Based on the risks in your premises and FSD requirements, we can advise on the type, number and location of fire extinguishers, fire blankets and sand buckets, supply FSD-approved portable equipment, and arrange inspections and the FS251. When you contact us, please provide the premises type, floor area, main risks and any FSD letter of requirements. You can also browse our Fire Safety Products, Annual Fire Inspection Guide and Service Coverage.

Enquire about portable fire equipment provision, or call 2667 7701.